Bayshore Park sits at 2545 South Bayshore Drive, across the street from Monty's and the marina. The 1960s building's units went to the same buyers at very different prices. In the summer of 2025, a joint venture of Mast Capital and BH Group bought 32 of its units at an average of $661,843 each. Early in 2026, the last seven owners received an average of $985,714, nearly $324,000 more per unit, The Real Deal reported.
That gap matters to anyone comparing older condos in Coconut Grove this season. Since 2025, four of the neighborhood's 1960s buildings have sold to developers, been bid on, or both. Their records show that the land value developers are chasing is real. They also show that it reaches unit owners unevenly, in rounds. The biggest gains went to the owners who sold last and to the investor who resold an assembled site. If you are buying into an older building, the developer's number is not your floor. What you are buying is a place in a sequence.
Bayshore Park Paid Its Owners in Three Rounds
The Bayshore Park assembly took about a decade. According to The Real Deal, Mast first targeted the building in the mid-2010s, paying $240,000 for a two-bedroom. Over the following years an affiliate bought 16 units at prices from $261,000 to $450,000.
The second round came in May and June of 2025. BH joined Mast, and the partnership bought 32 units, including the 16 Mast already held, for a combined $21.1 million. The third round was the seven holdouts at roughly $6.9 million together, which brought the full 39-unit building to about $28 million. Those last seven owners had bought in the early 2000s for an average of $100,000.
The owners who sold one at a time, years before an assembly looked certain, got the lowest prices. The owners who sold in the group round got the middle price. The owners who held out until they were the last obstacle got the highest.
At Chateau Grove, the Second Sale Paid More Than the First
Two blocks of Virginia Street show what happens once the owners have been bought out. Chateau Grove is a two-story, 25-unit building from 1963 at 3265 Virginia Street. In 2025 the Canero Group paid $17.3 million to buy out its individual owners and converted the building to rentals. In April 2026, El-Ad National Properties paid $45.5 million for the same property, which Coconut Grove Spotlight described as nearly three times what Canero had paid a year earlier.
The former owners received about $692,000 per unit on average. El-Ad's price works out to roughly $1.82 million for each of the 25 units. The owners went through the slow buyout process, and the investor who completed it captured the larger share of the increase.
The same Spotlight report linked this demand to rising real estate values and to zoning changes that give developers new options to build larger and denser. The value of a site rises with what can be built on it, and the people who own the units under the old building are not always the ones who collect it.
Virginia Pointe Was Bought for Rent, Not for a Tower
Next door at 3245 Virginia Street, Virginia Pointe came out differently. This 1966 complex has 66 units. In the spring of 2026, Canero Group and 8K Capital bought 59 of them for $27.7 million, an average of $470,000 per unit acquired. The Real Deal reported that the buyers had no immediate plan to redevelop and would run the units as rentals.
Virginia Pointe has the lowest per-unit figure of the four buildings, and it is the one where the buyer described a hold strategy. A majority purchase that ends in rentals instead of a new building is still a buyout. For an owner, it sets a price without starting the land race that produced Bayshore Park's last round or Chateau Grove's resale.
The Mutiny Bid Rose and Fell With the Repair Bill
The Mutiny has been the Grove's most closely watched test. It was built in 1968 as Coconut Grove's first high-rise and stands 12 stories on South Bayshore Drive. BH Group offered $160 million for its 170 residences, a simple average of about $941,000 per unit. In August 2026, Coconut Grove Spotlight reported that the offer had expired without enough owners agreeing to sell. It was the third attempt in less than two years to buy the building, after earlier offers from DaGrosa Capital and Slate Property Group.
The Spotlight account shows how much the bid depended on the cost of keeping the building. The buyer's representative said BH Group had been told to expect a special assessment of roughly $30 million. He said a later estimate came in much lower, and that this made the buyout less compelling to owners. The condo association's president said the building had never discussed the $30 million figure. The buyer's representative put the offers at 70 to 100 percent above market value based on the last closed sale. He also said the bid was more than the land was worth to BH Group in today's market.
One owner told the Spotlight the offer was a pretty good price for the current market, and added that the proceeds would buy "little, if anything" in the Grove. Owners measure a buyout against what it costs to stay in the neighborhood, not against the building's last resale. A premium over a 1968 building's comps can still fall short of a new home a few blocks away, and that is one reason a large share of owners at The Mutiny turned the offer down.
What the Finished Product Sells For
The new buildings explain why developers keep making these offers. Mast and BH plan Raffles Residences Coconut Grove for the Bayshore Park site, a 10-story building with 35 residences designed by Brandon Haw Architecture, as the Miami Herald reported. The Real Deal reported that prices start at $4.5 million, the unit mix runs from two to four-and-a-half bedrooms plus four penthouses, and the developers expected sales to open this fall. It is the first standalone Raffles residential project.
Spread the $28 million buyout across those 35 new residences and the land cost comes to about $800,000 per home, against a starting price of $4.5 million. Construction, design and the brand account for much of the difference. Even so, the old owners' best price of $985,714 is a small fraction of what one new home on the same lot is expected to sell for.
Other Grove projects show the same pricing. In an October 2, 2026 price snapshot, Haute Residence listed Four Seasons Private Residences Coconut Grove from $5.62 million, about $2,500 per square foot, and THE WELL from $1.5 million, about $1,200 per square foot. Both are estimated for 2028 delivery. The same guide listed Arbor's remaining homes from $1.8 million in a 45-residence building delivered in 2026. That is the price ladder a Mutiny owner faces when weighing sale proceeds against staying in the Grove.
Reading an Older Grove Listing in November
Developers say plainly that they will keep looking. At The Real Deal's Miami forum on November 5, panelists from Two Roads, BH Group and 13th Floor Investments said developers often offer unit owners more than market value. Taylor Collins of Two Roads spoke about the roughly $50 million his firm paid in August to settle with the holdouts at Biscayne 21 in Edgewater. "I like to say 'I think we bought it twice,'" he said. In Edgewater as at Bayshore Park, the last owners to settle were the most expensive for the developer.
The countywide resale market gives this context. In September 2026, Miami-Dade had 12.3 months of condo supply, down from 14.0 a year earlier. The median condo sale price was $417,090, down 0.7% year over year, and sellers received 94% of their original list price, according to MIAMI REALTORS. In that resale market, buyers have room to negotiate. The Grove's land market for older waterfront buildings runs on a separate clock, one bid at a time.
For a buyer, that means looking at an older Grove condo on two levels. One is the home itself, priced against resale comps that the county figures say are soft. The other is the building's place in the sequence above. Has a developer already bought units one at a time, the way Mast did at Bayshore Park for years? Is a majority already held by an investor planning rentals, as at Virginia Pointe? Has a bid already failed because the owners' repair bill turned out smaller than expected, as at The Mutiny? A buyer who pays a premium expecting a buyout is betting on the last round. The Grove's 2025 and 2026 records show that round can pay very well, and they also show it can stall without a date.
This post is general market information, not legal, tax or financial advice. If you are considering a unit in a building where a buyout or assessment is in play, confirm your own situation with the right professionals.
If you are weighing an older Coconut Grove condo, or a new building like the one planned for the Bayshore Park site, a conversation with Kara Cugno before you make an offer is a discreet place to start, with guidance across Miami and South Florida. Request a Private Consultation.